Let’s face it: we all dread the day it gets too cold to swim each year. The day you step outside, smell the pumpkin spice, feel a nippy breeze, and dip your pool into what feels like a lake in winter. But what if you could extend the afternoons of enjoyment for just a little longer? A gas pool heater can help you do just that.
For many, a pool heater is 100% worth it. If you want warm water fast and don’t mind a matching gas bill, you will likely benefit. This isn’t for those on a tight budget. A gas heater is quick off the line, but not cheap to keep running.
Aloha Pools & Spas has been helping families in Union City, Jonesboro, Cape Girardeau, Marion, and the St. Louis area for 57 years, and more than 40 certified pool operators are on our team. For this guide, we went straight to the source. Raypak builds gas pool heaters, and they came in to train our staff. On that same day, we sat down with TJ, a Raypak regional service and training manager with about 24 years at the company, and Alex, a local Raypak sales rep. What they told us is the backbone of this post. You can watch the full conversation in our podcast episode on Raypak pool heaters.
Want to talk heaters with a real person? Call any of our stores or schedule a free consultation, and we will help you size one for your pool.
What is a gas pool heater, and how does it work?
A gas pool heater burns gas to warm your pool water as it flows through the heater. Heat is measured in BTUs, a unit of heat. A bigger BTU number means more heating power.
Our guests made the math sound easy. You figure out how many BTUs your pool needs, then divide that by how many BTUs the heater puts out. The answer is how many hours the heater has to run. Fewer hours means less money spent on gas. Raypack has a cost estimator tool based on how much time your family spends in the pool.
What are the pros and cons of a gas pool heater at a glance?
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Heats water fast | Gas bills can add up |
| Works on short notice, any time of year | Wrong size means wasted money |
| Sizing is simple math | Year-round swimming takes more work than it sounds |
| Can team up with a heat pump | Up-front costs go beyond the heater |
What are the 4 pros of a gas pool heater?
1. A gas pool heater heats fast.
Our guests used a car comparison that stuck with us. Gas heaters are the Trans Am of pool heating: zero to sixty, right now. If you want to jump in on Easter weekend or warm up a chilly pool for a birthday party, a gas heater gets you there quickly.
2. It works when the weather will not cooperate.
Anyone in the Mid-South knows how fast the weather can flip, no matter the time of year. One of our guests pointed out that it can be cold the week before Thanksgiving, then turn warm on the holiday. A gas heater can warm the water on short notice so the kids (or the brave uncle) can still get in. Same goes for a warm spell around Christmas.
3. Sizing is straightforward with a gas pool heater.
One of our guests called the sizing formula “stupid easy.” It comes down to the BTUs you need and the BTUs the heater puts in. A good sizing conversation covers three things: where your pool is, what your pool is like, and what you expect from it. More on that below.
4. It can team up with a heat pump.
Our guests talked about hybrid systems, where a gas heater and a heat pump work together. They said that setup could be even better for some pools. For the full story on heat pumps, listen to our podcast with TTI FAB, More Than You Wanted to Know About Heat Pumps.

What are the 4 cons of a gas pool heater?
1. The pool heater gas bill is real.
This is the number one worry we hear, and guests said customers ask two things right away: what it will cost to install, and what it will cost to run each month. A gas heater running more than seven or eight hours a day gets expensive fast. The fix usually starts with sizing the heater right and keeping the heat in the water, not with running it harder.
2. The wrong heater is a waste.
If you sell a Trans Am to a Honda family, they get the first gas bill and never fire it up again. Some folks want speed no matter the price. Others want to take the chill off. Neither is wrong, but the heater has to match the person. When you replace a heater, a good first question is whether the old one did the job before it quit. If it did, the old unit’s BTU input is a great starting point.
3. Year-round swimming is harder than it sounds.
Plenty of people tell us they need a gas heater because they plan to swim all year. However, this is not always the best idea.
In very cold, windy weather, a heated pool can lose four to six inches of water a day to steam. That means an autofill that runs constantly, and water chemistry that is always a little out of balance. They also warned about freezing: a heater exchanges heat very well, but it also exchanges cold very well. If the pump or power goes out on a freezing night, the heat exchanger is the first thing to freeze.
Their advice for true year-round swimming is to build an enclosure around the pool, and that is a whole different project with its own humidity challenges. For most Mid-South backyards, a heater is better used to stretch the shoulder seasons.
4. Up-front costs go beyond the heater.
Buyers often forget that the heater is only part of the install- the pad, the valves, and the labor all count. Our guests said the first question customers ask is what it will cost to install the heater. For a look at other costs people overlook, see our post on the hidden costs of building a pool.
Not sure if a heater fits your budget? Get a free estimate or stop by a nearby store.
How big of a gas pool heater do I need?
Everybody wants to know how long it will take to heat their pool- it depends, and gallons are not the first thing to ask about. The most important number is your pool’s surface area, because the surface is, as one guest put it, the big hole at the top where the heat races out. Gallons come second.
Then comes everything else:
- How windy your yard is. Wind takes the life out of a pool’s heat.
- The outside temperature.
- Where the water starts and where you want it to end up.
- The coldest day you expect to swim.
- Extras like waterfalls and fountains.
- What you expect from the heater. Taking the chill off for a few weeks is a different job from swimming in February.
This is true whether your pool is inground, semi-inground, or above ground. The same math applies.
Since heat leaves through the surface, a cover can make a big difference in how long your heater runs. [LINK NEEDED: U.S. Department of Energy or similar source on pool covers reducing heat loss] We cover the pros, cons, and costs in our post on swimming pool covers. Heater not your only upgrade question? Our guide to pool features worth the money can help you decide.
Should I choose a gas heater or a heat pump?
The main difference is upfront cost vs. ongoing cost. Gas is faster. A heat pump uses electricity and can run longer. One more perk they love: some heat pumps can cool your pool, too. That matters with the opposite weather of heat pump days- the days where your water feels like hot soup.
The right answer depends on your pool, your climate, and your habits. If you already have, or plan to add, an automatic cover, it can work well with a heat pump, and one of our guests uses that combo at home. Want the full heat pump rundown? Listen to our heat pump podcast.
What temperature should I set my pool to?
There is no perfect number. One guest said that 86 degrees feels perfect on a 98-degree day, but one person may want 70 and another may want 98. Figure our your target, and size your heater for the temperature you actually want.
How do I keep heater costs under control?
- Get the size right at the start, and tell us honestly how you plan to swim.
- Keep heat from escaping with a cover.
- Skip the urge to run it all day, every day.
- Stay on top of upkeep.
- Call our service and repair team if your current heater is acting up.
Frequently asked questions
Is a gas pool heater worth it?
For many families, yes. It heats fast and works on short notice. It is less of a fit if you want to swim all winter on a small budget, since gas costs and water loss add up in cold weather.
How long does it take a gas heater to heat a pool?
It depends on your pool’s surface area, size, wind, outside temperature, starting water temperature, and your target temperature. That is why we size each pool one at a time instead of guessing from gallons alone.
How big of a pool heater do I need?
You need enough BTUs to meet your pool’s heat demand, and the number of hours the heater runs comes from dividing the BTUs you need by the BTUs the heater puts out. Your pool’s location, features, and swim goals all factor in.
Can I swim all year with a gas heater?
You can try, but it is hard in most areas. In very cold weather, you may lose several inches of water a day, and a heat exchanger can freeze if the pump or power goes out. Most owners use a heater to stretch the spring and fall seasons.
What is the difference between a gas heater and a heat pump?
A gas heater burns gas to heat quickly, while a heat pump takes longer, uses electricity, and some models can also cool the water. Some pools use both together.
Ready to heat your swim season?
Start with a free estimate, then schedule a consultation so our team can size a heater for your pool. Prefer to talk? Call Union City at (731) 885-2020, Jonesboro at (870) 336-ALOHA, O’Fallon at (314) 788-POOL, Cape Girardeau at (573) 335-1523, or Marion at (618) 619-SWIM.
Still shopping for the pool itself? Let a sale’s rep know, or check out our guide to the best time of year to buy a pool to see if now’s the time.
